- The new device, which was designed for people to lose weight, is facing a backlash, as experts say that it is not medically healthy, it is harmful.
- The DentalSlim Diet Control uses magnets with the wearer on the teeth to limit the ability to fully open the mouth. People with limited mobility should be committed to a liquid diet.
- Experts say the device is dangerous, putting people at risk of malnutrition.
The new device, which is designed for people to lose weight, has been sharply criticized for being harmful, misrepresenting the causes and treatment of obesity, which at the same time contributes to fatphobia.
Researchers in the United Kingdom at the University of Otago in New Zealand have developed a device called the DentalSlim Diet Control, which is installed by a dentist with “magnets” and screws to limit the opening of the jaw by up to 2 millimeters.
The device facilitates weight loss, as the wearer’s ability to open his mouth is limited, և they have to rely on a liquid diet.
In a statement from the University of Otago, Professor Paul Brownton, a lead researcher, said that the DentalSlim Diet Control is an effective, safe and affordable tool for obese people.
However, the device has been widely criticized for not only being medically unhealthy but also for leading carriers to malnutrition.
An article published by the researchers found that several participants who took part in the DentalSlim Diet Control study “only occasionally” felt tense, confused by the device, and said that life was less satisfying while wearing it.
In a statement, Brunton said, “The key to successful weight loss for people is fitness, it helps them to establish new habits, which allows them to maintain a low-calorie diet for some time. It really starts the process. ”
According to Brunton, the device is “a non-invasive, reversible, economically-attractive alternative to surgery.”
However, not everyone agrees. In response: University tweet Following the press release of the invention, many people called the online design a “torture device” and said it was fatobic.
Others asked how patients would be able to stand up if they got sick by comparing the device to the use of jaw wires for weight loss (an old-fashioned practice of closing people’s jaws by preventing them from eating).
“It has been hailed as a positive step in the fight against obesity,” he said. Settlement of Very Disorders անդամ Member of the Academy of Eating Disorders, says Verywell.
Federick adds that the development of the device and its protection by scientists “show a gross lack of understanding of the science of weight, obesity and eating disorders.”
Dietary restrictions do not cure obesity
Experts say that one of the main drawbacks of the DentalSlim Diet Control device is that it supposedly helps fight obesity, but dietary restrictions do not work for weight loss. Eating nutritious foods promotes good health, but diet does not work in the long run.
Such a device repeats messages that greatly simplify the knowledge of weight: knowledge.
– Amanda Raful
Harvard T. Amanda Raful, a postgraduate researcher at the Chan School of Public Health և Boston Children’s Hospital Strategic Training Initiative, tells Verywell that cultural, often medical, story that weight is controlled by changing your mind. to eat և how much you exercise is wrong.
Instead, Raffles says, science has shown us that genetics, along with biological, psychological and social factors, affect someone’s body weight. In other words, dieting or being overweight will not fundamentally change your body’s shape.
“Such a device replicates messages that greatly simplify the science of weight and knowledge,” says Raful.
Recovery after restriction
Terry Marquez, CEO of Bellwood Health Services in Toronto, tells Verywell that research has shown that when someone is on a diet or planning to lose weight, “about 95%” of weight loss is restored fairly quickly. :
“The body has a huge ability to maintain the weight it wants to have,” says Marquez. In fact, a systematic review of weight loss programs has shown that after 12 months of dieting, the effects of weight loss have largely disappeared.
“It is not uncommon for individuals to simply move on to the next weight loss program, accepting that they are the ones who have failed to lose weight. “They did not have enough willpower,” Marquez said. “They rarely question the effectiveness of a weight loss device or program.”
The body has a huge ability to protect the weight it wants to be on.
– Terry Marquez
Instead, Marquez says, the body needs proper nutrition from carbohydrates, proteins, and fats to function. Denying the body the fuel it needs to survive on a liquid diet is not conducive to a normal diet.
Even the results of the DentalSlim Diet Control study found that two weeks after the device was removed, all participants regained weight. Federicki believes that the very nature of the research is problematic, as evidenced by the size of its incredibly small sample of seven, as well as its poorly informed stance on writing.
The perpetuation of dangerous ար fake stories
Federick, who specializes in eating disorders, says that despite the science of weight and biology, the device’s creators claim that calorie restriction “should be successful,” but he argues that the effects are insignificant or only successful in the short term. that of “bad motivation” չ not sticking to lifestyle changes.
Anita Federick, PhD
The inability to lose weight or change body weight has nothing to do with your motivation or your personality.
– Anita Federick, Ph.D.
In their article, the authors wrote that obese people “usually have an addictive person – sweet food impulsivity” – suffer from eating disorders.
“It is horrible to see such a statement in 2021,” said Federico. “I want every reader to know that the inability to maintain or change weight has nothing to do with your motivation or your personality.”
“For most people, eating a low-calorie diet will be a powerful biological impulse to eat,” says Federick. “It’s not impulsive, it’s the effect of hunger, it’s good. in documented research experiments. ”
A complete approach to icy embedding
Vijaya Surampudy, a medical assistant at UCLA’s Department of Human Nutrition who works at the Center for Obesity and Metabolic Health, tells Verywell that treating obesity goes far beyond calorie restriction.
There are many environmental, psychosocial, genetic and hormonal factors that play a role in one’s body size, which means that a complete approach is needed.
“The most effective treatment for obesity is a health journey; it is a long-term process of lifestyle change,” says Surampudi. “We all need support to make lifestyle changes, so finding health professionals to help you travel will be essential.”
How Diet և Harmful Devices Affect Eating Disorders
Weight discrimination is prevalent in our daily lives. Consumers are bombarded with “flattening” teas, bodybuilders, diet programs, and exercise programs that focus only on total weight loss instead of overall health. Experts say that these weight loss habits are not only unstable, but can also lead to eating disorders or eating disorders.
Rafful says the early sign or risk factor for an eating disorder is regular diet. A weight loss device like the DentalSlim Diet Control will initially cause weight change because people do not eat.
“But what happens is that when someone starts eating again, they will inevitably come back,” Raful said. “And that dissatisfaction with the body այդ that period of weight cycling actually increases the risk of developing eating disorders in the future.”
Federick says that it is important to note that about 30% of people with larger bodies suffer from Binge Eating Disorder (BED). Moreover, stigma, bias, and lack of accurate information mean that many people with BED do not really know they have an eating disorder.
“When they ask for help, they go to weight loss clinics and bariatric surgery consultations,” says Federick. “They are rarely evaluated or treated by orthopedic specialists who have evidence-based treatment for overeating.”
The DentalSlim Diet Control is designed for obese people, some of whom may be bedridden, even if they are unaware of it. It is “terrible” for Federico to think that “people with eating disorders will be targeted for this device.”
What does this mean for you?
New equipment designed to treat obesity is being criticized online for boosting unhealthy eating habits. Experts say that a device that uses magnets to restrict the mobility of the jaw is not medically useful and can lead to the development of eating disorders.